The picture
Pastel on blue-grey paper mounted on canvas, Museu Nacional d'Art de Catalunya, Barcelona. Pierre-Louis Laideguive, Parisian notary — a professional man of the robe's practical rank, no financier-prince — sits half-length in dark coat and neat wig, papers at hand, the face turned to the viewer with the mature La Tour address in its gravest register: attention complete, the smile held at the eyes only, the notary's professional virtues — discretion, exactness, the keeping of other men's secrets — legible in the set of the mouth. Exhibited at the Salon of 1761, it is the principal La Tour in Spain and the MNAC's key French eighteenth-century picture.
The bourgeois La Tour
The picture's interest begins with its rank. The famous La Tours are kings and philosophes; the working La Tour, Salon by Salon, portrayed precisely such men as Laideguive — the notaries, magistrates, doctors and fermiers of professional Paris — and the essay's phrase for his politics, the democracy of attention, is nowhere better tested: the notary receives exactly the apparatus the king received — the woven flesh, the double catch-light, the address at talking distance — with the rhetoric adjusted only to temperament: no dazzle, no accessories of wit; instead the professional's balanced, receiving look, the face of a man to whom one is about to entrust a will. Critics of the 1761 Salon singled the portrait out for truth (the year's entries were thin — the late phase beginning — and Laideguive stood among the proofs the machine still worked); modern criticism values it for the same quality under a sharper name: it is one of the most convincing portraits of listening in European art — the reactive half of conversation, which portraiture almost never attempts, given entire.
To Barcelona
The pastel's road to Catalonia ran through the post-Revolutionary dispersals and the nineteenth-century trade to the great Barcelona collections (the Cambó bequest's era of French acquisitions built the MNAC's old-master wing), and its presence there has a pedagogical consequence the museum understands: Iberia's public collections are nearly empty of French pastel — Spain's eighteenth century looked to Mengs and Goya — and Laideguive stands alone as the peninsula's demonstration of the medium at mastery: generations of Spanish visitors have learned what pastel could be from this one discreet notary, which would have amused the sitter's profession and satisfied the artist's vanity in equal measure.
What to look at
The eyes' engagement — the listening look: follow the picture's address and notice you have, involuntarily, begun composing what to say; the mouth's professional neutrality, warmth banked but present — compare Voltaire's irony or the Amiens laugh to measure how finely the register is tuned; the coat's dark economy against the paper's cool (the palette's sobriety itself a characterisation); the hands and papers, the tools of a documentary life given still-life dignity; and the condition — the surface's bloom intact after its long travels, the medium's paradoxical durability once more: the notary has kept his own file perfectly, as notaries should, and looks out from 1761 ready, imperturbably, for one more client. A pendant portrait of his wife is recorded in the literature; the pair's separation leaves Barcelona's notary listening, appropriately, alone.